Eat. Drink. Be Murdered.

Pittsburgh's Premier Murder Mystery Dinner Company

As of July 2015 McCaffery Mysteries Inc. is now operating under

Mystery Theatre Pittsburgh. Same great mystery shows, new name.

We specialize in comedic murder mystery productions and have produced over 500 performances. We have traveled throughout the tri-state area performing for various venues and special events including fundraisers, birthdays, corporate dinners, ice-breakers and team-building workshops. In addition to private bookings, Mystery Theatre Pittsburgh has performed, and continues to perform, for public audiences in various restaurant locations. We hire professional actors and our scripts are written by award-winning authors.

Mystery Theatre Pittsburgh will work tirelessly to ensure that your event is a successful one. We work with you and the venue staff map out a timeline for your event. Everything is planned from set up to breakdown - without surprises. Whether a single night performance with a simple buffet dinner or a murder mystery weekend with a Scavenger hunt and team building - your event will run smoothly.

We understand that you may have additional questions regarding our company and the different productions we perform. It would be our pleasure to schedule a meeting to discuss the possibilities of what we may offer your group.

Please do not hesitate to contact us with questions you may have, for additional information or to schedule a meeting.

Meet Pittsburgh's Murder Mystery Dinner Crew

Interested in joining our team? Email Lacy at Lacy@MysteryPittsburgh.com